The Best Crib Mattress in 2024

Choosing the perfect crib mattress for your baby can be daunting, with safety and comfort on the line. A suitable mattress ensures snug sleep and is crucial for your little one's development. Our guide simplifies all you need to know, from top recommendations to essential features that promise peace of mind and restful nights. Keep reading; we're here to help you find the best nest for your bundle of joy!

What to Look for in a Crib Mattress

When looking for a crib mattress, it’s important to consider safety certifications, material quality, comfort and support for your baby, and breathability and durability. These factors will ensure a safe and comfortable sleeping environment for your little one.

Safety Certifications

Safety certifications are a must when picking the best crib mattress for your little one. Look for seals of approval from reputable organizations like the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) and the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM).

These endorsements mean the mattress meets strict safety standards, protecting your baby from potential hazards. A certified safe crib mattress will fit snugly in a standard-sized crib—no more than 6 inches thick and at least 27¼ inches by 51¼ inches—to prevent any risks of entrapment or suffocation.

Furthermore, choosing a product that is specifically tested to reduce the risk of SIDS can bring added peace of mind; some mattresses are designed to be air-permeable, which can be safer for babies.

Always check that the crib mattress doesn’t sink under your baby’s weight, as this ensures their head and body are supported correctly night after night. Once you’re confident about safety, focus on gauging material quality to provide long-lasting comfort and durability for your child’s restful sleep.

Material Quality

When selecting the best crib mattress for your baby, you want to ensure it’s made from high-quality, safe materials. Look closely at what each mattress comprises; some are organic or have hypoallergenic covers, which can be crucial for babies with sensitive skin or allergies.

The fill material should also be non-toxic and free of harmful chemicals like phthalates and lead, which may affect your little one’s health.

As new moms, you’ll find that the market offers a variety of options when it comes to materials. A good choice maintains its shape and firmness to provide consistent support for your growing child.

For instance, the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer uses a dual-sided foam design, providing comfort and durability through the infant and toddler years. Prioritize mattresses like this that offer longevity without compromising on firmness essential for safe sleep.

Now, let’s consider how these materials translate into “Comfort and Support” for our precious little ones as they rest in their cribs.

Comfort and Support

A good crib mattress should support your baby’s growing body. This means the mattress keeps its shape and doesn’t sag under your little one’s weight, which is crucial for bone development and spinal alignment.

The best crib mattresses maintain a balance of comfort that soothes your baby without being overly soft, as too much softness can be unsafe.

Look for products like the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer or Delta Eco Classica III, known for their supportive construction tailored to infants’ needs. These mattresses are designed to prevent sinking while providing a cozy sleep surface.

Pediatricians often recommend picking a crib mattress that combines solid support with comfortable cushioning to promote healthy growth and restful sleep for babies.

Breathability and Durability

Breathable crib mattresses help prevent overheating and provide fresh air flow for your baby. Look for options that allow air to circulate freely, like those with built-in vents or made from mesh materials.

This feature can greatly reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), as some studies suggest well-ventilated sleep surfaces are safer for infants.

Durability is also key to a mattress’s long-term value. High-quality materials resist wear and tear, ensuring the mattress supports your child safely for years. Firm foam or coil springs should hold their shape over time, preventing any hazardous dips or soft spots from forming.

The best crib mattress will maintain its firmness because it’s not just an infant investment—it transitions into a toddler bed, too.

Moving on to our top picks.

Top Picks for the Best Crib Mattress

Avocado Organic Crib Mattress

Restful slumber

Cooling and breathable mattress pad for a restful baby sleep.
Best Overall

Find on Amazon


  • Made with organic cotton and other natural materials for a safe and comfortable sleep environment for babies

  • Hand-washable cover material for easy cleaning and maintenance

  • Avocado green color adds a unique and fun touch to the nursery

  • Durable and premium construction for long-lasting use

  • Standard crib size of 52 x 28 inches fits most standard cribs

  • Manufactured by ZZCshop, a trusted brand in baby products

Embracing eco-friendly choices for your baby’s sleep environment starts with the Avocado Organic Crib Mattress. This premium mattress supports sustainability and comfort, making it a top choice for new moms who prioritize organic materials and a healthier nursery. The core of this crib mattress is constructed from organic latex, cotton, and wool, which work together to provide natural temperature regulation — an essential feature to ensure that your baby remains cool during summer nights while being cozy enough in winter.

Durability is paramount in products designed for children, and the xigua Avocado Baby Summer Sleeping Pad meets this demand. Its resilience against countless wash cycles without sacrificing softness is just one of the reasons why we place it at the forefront of our recommendations. It adeptly balances hygiene with usability; its waterproof properties mean quick cleanups after nighttime accidents while shielding the mattress below from moisture.

New moms will appreciate these practical features and how this mattress respects their infant’s delicate skin. The velvety-soft touch surface avoids irritation while still allowing airflow—this enhances breathability, leading to better sleep quality for babies. Additionally, its generous sizing ensures ample room for growth and movement within the crib space. With a convenient design that includes an accompanying pillowcase and multifunctional uses extending beyond just as a sleeping pad—from playmats to picnic mats—the xigua Avocado pads are versatile companions through different stages of your child’s early years.


  • Machine washable up to 100+ cycles

  • Reusable and durable

  • Oversized at 52” x 28” with pillowcase included

  • Velvety soft, breathable, and noise-free for peaceful sleep


  • Limited size options (only 52″ x 28″)

  • May not be suitable for all crib mattress sizes

  • Washing and care instructions may be too restrictive for some users

Attention all new parents! Are you looking for a high-quality, eco-friendly organic crib mattress that will keep your baby cool and comfortable during hot summer nights? Look no further than the xigua Avocado Organic Crib Mattress. Perfect for health-conscious, environmentally-aware individuals who want the best for their little ones. Get yours today and give your baby the gift of a restful night’s sleep on our premium cooling pad.

Serta Perfect Start Crib and Toddler Mattress

Great features

Safe, waterproof, dual-sided – ideal for infants and toddlers.
Runner Up

Find on Amazon


  • Waterproof and stain-resistant for easy cleaning

  • Made with durable, lightweight materials

  • Features memory foam comfort layer for optimal support

  • Greenguard Gold is certified for low chemical emissions

  • Double-sided design for extended use as a toddler mattress

  • Hand wash-only care instructions to maintain quality over time

The Serta Perfect Start Crib and Toddler Mattress shines as a top choice for new moms seeking peace of mind as their little one slumbers. Crafted with care in the USA, this mattress boasts a sustainable fiber core sourced from upcycled plastic bottles, striking an impressive balance between being eco-friendly and providing firm support essential for your baby’s growth and development. The dual-sided design grows with your child, starting as a snug crib fit and then flipping to accommodate the leap into toddler bedding—all while maintaining its shape thanks to the lightweight yet durable construction.

Ease-of-use is paramount for nursery essentials; Serta delivers with a waterproof vinyl cover that makes cleanup swift after those inevitable spills. Health shouldn’t be compromised for functionality—rest assured knowing this mattress has been awarded the GREENGUARD Gold certification for low chemical emissions, fostering better indoor air quality around your baby. It also meets rigorous flammability tests without using toxic fire retardants—a testament to safety-first engineering.

Our selection of the Serta Perfect Start at number two on our list reflects its excellent harmony of safety features, environmental stewardship, and user convenience. These hallmarks set apart a superior crib mattress. A seven-year warranty underscores long-term reliability, easing new mom concerns about frequent replacements or wear-out woes. This isn’t just another piece in your nursery; it’s an investment in your baby’s healthy sleep journey from infancy through toddler years.


  • Waterproof cover for easy cleaning and durability

  • Dual-sided design for extended use as baby grows into a toddler

  • GREENGUARD Gold is certified for low chemical emissions

  • Made in the USA with a 7-year warranty


  • May take 24 – 72 hours to expand after delivery fully

  • Vinyl cover may not be as breathable as other materials

  • Limited 7-year warranty compared to some competitors offering longer warranties

The Serta Perfect Start Crib and Toddler Mattress is perfect for new parents looking for a safe, high-quality mattress for their little one’s crib that will transition to a toddler bed. Made in the USA with non-toxic materials and a waterproof cover, this mattress is ideal for infants and toddlers alike. Upgrade your child’s sleep game today!

Newton Crib Mattress

Peace of mind

Breathable, washable, safe: Best for baby’s sleep and safety.
Most Safe

Find on Amazon


  • Made with Wovenaire material for breathability and water resistance

  • Hypoallergenic and washable for easy cleaning

  • Removable cover for convenience

  • Encased coil design for support and comfort

  • Fits standard crib dimensions (52″L x 28″W x 5.5″Th)

  • Designed and manufactured in the USA

In the world of baby sleep, the Newton Baby Crib Mattress is a standout choice for parents prioritizing infant safety and comfort. This mattress checks all the boxes: it’s 100% breathable, reducing the risk of suffocation and giving new moms peace of mind as their little ones slumber. This feature, with its patented core composition allows babies to breathe through the mattress, a brilliant innovation in crib mattress design.

Moreover, its washability from cover to core eases any hygiene concerns. Inevitable spills or accidents accompanying those early years are no match for this mattress. The convenience here cannot be overstated. Fewer worries about bacteria or mold build-up means more quality rest for babies and their tired moms. Plus, with no foam, latex, or springs, parents can rest assured knowing they’re providing a non-toxic sleeping environment.

We rank this product at number three because while it excels in safety features and material quality—arguably some of the most critical factors—it may fall just short when comparing cost-effectiveness against other top contenders.


  • Reduces suffocation risk for infants

  • 2 – stage design supports baby’s natural posture as they grow

  • Completely washable from cover to core for easy cleaning

  • Breathable technology allows for safer sleep surface


  • Expensive compared to traditional crib mattresses

  • Only available in white color, it may show stains more easily

  • Not waterproof, may require additional mattress pad for accidents

Attention all new and expecting parents! Are you looking for the perfect crib mattress for your precious little one? Look no further than Newton Crib Mattress, designed by parents for parents. This 2-stage, washable, and breathable mattress is ideal for safety-conscious parents who want to give their baby the best start. Say goodbye to suffocation risks and hello to a good night’s sleep. Upgrade your baby’s bed today with Newton Crib Mattress!

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress

Personalized comfort

Exceptional support and comfort for newborns and toddlers.
Best Memory Foam

Find on Amazon


  • Made with premium memory foam for maximum comfort and support

  • Waterproof design for easy cleaning and protection against accidents

  • Durable construction for long-lasting use

  • Specifically designed to fit standard crib sizes

  • Hand wash only for convenient maintenance

  • Electric-free, making it safe for use in a nursery environment

For new moms seeking peace of mind, the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress is a standout choice. Crafted with CertiPUR-US-certified foam, this mattress takes into account both health and environmental concerns—no hazardous chemicals here! It’s an intelligent design decision that prioritizes your baby’s well-being without compromising quality.

The dual-sided feature of the Little Dreamer is particularly noteworthy. One side caters to infants with high-density foam for firmer support during their fragile early months, while the toddler side transitions to plush foam. The latter is great for offering a softer surface tailored for growing toddlers. The convenience doesn’t end there; caring for this crib mattress is a breeze thanks to its waterproof and durable stretch-knit fabric. Grab a damp sponge with some warm, soapy water (steering clear from those harsh chemicals), and cleanup becomes less of a chore—a game-changer for busy new mothers.

Moreover, every aspect of the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer serves functionality married with durability—from its hypoallergenic medical-grade material down to its secure-sewn seams, which resist wear over time. As your child grows from infant to playful tot ready for more cushioned comfort, let the arrows on the mattress tag be your guide in flipping it over effortlessly. We love this thoughtful detail, allowing you and your baby continuity in quality sleep without interruption.


  • Long-lasting with a lifetime policy for peace of mind

  • Certified safe for children with no harsh chemicals

  • Waterproof and durable for easy cleaning and comfortable sleep

  • Dual-sided design supports newborns and toddlers, providing long-term use


  • The mattress is on the pricier side compared to other crib mattresses

  • Some customers may find the mattress to be too firm for their baby’s comfort

  • The waterproof cover can be noisy and crinkly, which might disrupt a baby’s sleep

Our Little Dreamer Crib Mattress from Moonlight Slumber is perfect for busy parents who want the best for their newborn or toddler. Made with certified safe materials and a waterproof, durable design, this 5-inch dual-sided mattress provides support and comfort for your little one’s growing needs. Don’t settle for less when it comes to your child’s sleep – choose our Little Dreamer Crib Mattress today!

Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress

Low-emission choice

Eco-conscious parents seeking safe, waterproof crib mattress for toddlers.
Best Eco-Friendly

Find on Amazon


  • Machine washable cover for easy cleaning

  • Waterproof material for added protection

  • Recommended firmness for safe and comfortable sleep

  • Greenguard certified for low chemical emissions

  • High-density foam fill for durability and support

  • Removable cover for added convenience

Sleep is precious for newborns and new moms who value every peaceful moment in which their little one rests. Enter the Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress – an award-winning comfort haven that stands out as a reliable choice without having to proclaim itself “The Best.” With its GREENGUARD Gold Certification and CertiPUR-US certified foam, this mattress offers peace of mind, ensuring your baby’s sleeping environment is free from harmful chemicals and off-gassing pollutants.

Durability meets convenience in this mattress; it’s designed to fit any standard full-size crib and toddler bed, growing seamlessly with your child. The machine-washable, waterproof cover simplifies cleanup after those inevitable accidents. A friend recently shared how she effortlessly zipped off the soiled cover and had it laundered without disrupting her baby’s sleep routine – truly a lifesaver at 2 AM! The hypoallergenic properties add another layer of protection against irritants which can disturb your child’s sleep.

A testament to thoughtful design, the Graco Premium Mattress boasts optimal firmness balanced by a soft outer layer for coziness. Its perforated foam core champions airflow while maintaining solid support for developing bones. Parents can rest easy knowing they’ve invested in quality backed by numerous accolades, including PTPA’s Top Product Award – all underlined by a robust 6-year warranty from Stork Craft Manufacturing (USA) Inc., assuring long-term reliability in nurturing sweet dreams night after night.


  • GREENGUARD Gold Certified for indoor air quality and safety

  • CertiPUR – US Certified Foam for a healthy sleeping environment

  • Machine washable cover with 100% waterproof sleep surface for easy cleaning

  • Fits standard full-size crib and toddler bed for long-lasting use


  • Limited color or design options for the machine – washable cover

  • May take up to 48 hours to fully expand after delivery

  • Polyester material may not be as breathable as other mattress materials

For the eco-conscious parent who prioritizes safety and convenience, the Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress is the perfect choice – certified for low chemical emissions and easy to clean with its waterproof cover. Upgrade your child’s sleep experience today by choosing The Best Crib Mattress.

Dream On Me Foam 2-in-1 Crib Mattress

Sink into it

Safe and comfortable choice for your little one’s crib.
Best Comfortable

Find on Amazon


  • 2-in-1 design for both crib and toddler bed

  • Memory foam comfort layer for added support

  • Waterproof and durable material for easy cleaning and longevity

  • Breathable cover for added comfort and safety

  • Made in the USA with high-quality materials

  • Fits standard size cribs (51.75″L x 27.5″W x 5″Th)

As new moms navigate the world of baby essentials, the Dream On Me Foam 2-in-1 Breathable Twilight Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress stands out for its thoughtful design and safety features. Made with care in the USA, this mattress stands out in quality and comfort. The dual-sided feature caters to your child’s needs as they grow; one side offers breathable material perfect for infants, while the toddler side boasts a waterproof cover to withstand inevitable spills. This ensures longevity of use from newborn stages into toddlerhood without sacrificing hygiene or ease of maintenance.

The Greenguard Gold Certification gives parents peace of mind, knowing their little one sleeps on a surface free from harmful chemicals and emissions. Moreover, the CertiPUR-US certified foam layers are hypoallergenic, which means better sleep for sensitive babies. New moms will appreciate how easy it is to keep clean—wipe down with soap and water. Plus, with its 88 interwoven steel coils, there’s an ideal balance between firm support and plush comfort that follows safety standards set by CPSC/ASTM.

This Dream On Me mattress fits snugly in standard-sized cribs and beds, eliminating gaps that might pose risks during sleep. Its reinforced waterproof cover resists stains while lock-stitched seams prevent fraying over time—a testament to durability. Remembering those early days when my friend’s little one had her first peaceful night’s rest on this mattress brings home just how essential choosing the right crib mattress can be for both baby’s development and parental sanity!


  • Hypoallergenic and CertiPUR-US-certified foam layers for cushioned comfort

  • Made in the USA with environmentally friendly, recyclable, non-toxic materials

  • Durable with 88 heat-tempered steel spring coils for comfort and support

  • Greenguard Gold Certified for optimum health and safety


  • Some customers may find it takes too long for the mattress to expand after delivery fully.

  • The waterproof cover on the toddler side may not be as breathable as the infant side, potentially causing discomfort for some children.

  • The mattress may be priced higher than other options on the market.

This mattress is perfect for the safety-conscious parent who wants a comfortable and durable option for their baby’s crib. Ideal for those looking for a certified and non-toxic option, this Dream On Me Foam 2-in-1 Crib Mattress is the best choice. Upgrade your little one’s sleeping experience today by clicking “add to cart” now!

Dourxi Crib Mattress


Dual-sided comfort memory foam crib mattress for infants and toddlers.
Most Convenient

Find on Amazon


  • 3-layered crib mattress with memory foam comfort layer

  • Removable cover for easy cleaning and maintenance

  • Lightweight and breathable for baby’s comfort

  • Made from wool, synthetic materials, and foam

  • 60-day no-questions-asked return policy and limited 10-year warranty

  • Available in blue and white color options

Ensuring your little one has a safe and comfortable sleep environment is a top priority for any new mom, and the Dourxi Crib Mattress delivers precisely that. Constructed with CertiPUR-US certified foam, this mattress steers clear of harmful substances you wouldn’t want near your baby – no phthalates, lead, or mercury in sight. The dual-sided design cleverly caters to different stages of a child’s growth; firmer support on one side creates an ideal sleep surface for infants, while the softer memory foam on the flip side suits older toddlers’ comfort preferences.

The thoughtful details don’t stop there – Dourxi understands that convenience is key to nursery furniture. The removable outer cover in chic white and sky blue complements various décor themes and makes maintenance a breeze; zip it off for washing to keep your crib space pristine. Moreover, its triple-layer breathable structure featuring gel-infused memory foam doesn’t just cradle your baby cozily. Still, it helps regulate temperature throughout the night by enhancing airflow and drawing away excess heat.

In addition to comfort features, parents can appreciate practical aspects like standard sizing at 52 x 27½ x 6 inches, making it compatible with most cribs and toddler beds, as well as easy transport as it arrives compressed in a portable box – all backed by substantial after-sale support including a 60-day return policy and limited 10-year warranty. With the Dourxi Crib Mattress nestled in your nursery, you’re setting up more than just sweet dreams–you’re ensuring peace of mind, too.


  • Non-toxic and certified foam for safe use

  • Standard size fits any standard crib, convertible crib, and toddler bed

  • Removable and washable outer cover for easy cleaning

  • Dual-sided with firmness options for infant and toddler comfort


  • It may have a slight odor initially

  • Some users may find the mattress too firm for their liking

  • Outer cover may shrink or warp after washing

The Dourxi Crib Mattress is perfect for the practical and safety-conscious parent who wants the best for their baby’s sleep. With its non-toxic materials, dual-sided comfort, and easy-to-clean cover, this mattress is ideal for anyone looking to provide a comfortable and safe environment for their little one. Don’t settle for less regarding your baby’s crib mattress – choose Dourxi.


Q: What should I look for when shopping for a crib mattress?

A: When shopping for a crib mattress, it’s important to look for one that is firm, fits snugly in the crib, and is made with breathable materials to reduce the risk of suffocation. Additionally, considering factors such as mattress firmness, size, and safety certifications can help you make an informed decision.

Q: Are organic crib mattresses better than non-organic ones?

A: Organic crib mattresses are often preferred by parents due to their use of natural, non-toxic materials and certifications that ensure the absence of harmful chemicals. However, both organic and non-organic crib mattresses must meet safety and firmness requirements to provide a safe sleep environment for babies.

Q: What is the best crib mattress for a newborn in 2023?

A: The “best” crib mattress for a newborn in 2023 can vary based on individual needs and preferences. Some popular options in 2023 include the Newton Baby Crib Mattress, Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress, and Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress. It’s important to consider factors such as safety, material composition, and reviews when choosing a crib mattress for a newborn.

Q: How do I ensure that my crib mattress is safe for my baby?

A: To ensure that your crib mattress is safe for your baby, look for certifications such as Greenguard Gold, which signifies low chemical emissions. Additionally, check for compliance with safety standards set by organizations like the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) to guarantee that the mattress meets essential safety criteria.

Q: What are the different types of crib mattresses available?

A: The market offers various types of crib mattresses, including foam mattresses, innerspring mattresses, organic crib mattresses, breathable crib mattresses, and mini crib mattresses. Each type has its own set of features and benefits, so it’s important to consider factors such as material, size, and safety when choosing the right type for your baby’s crib.

Q: Is a breathable crib mattress necessary for a baby’s sleep?

A: A breathable crib mattress is designed to promote air circulation and reduce the risk of suffocation, making it an important consideration for a baby’s sleep environment. While not mandatory, choosing a breathable crib mattress can provide added peace of mind for parents and help create a safer sleeping space for infants and toddlers.

Q: How do I choose the best crib mattress for a toddler?

A: When choosing a crib mattress for a toddler, consider factors such as firmness, material durability, and mattress size to ensure a comfortable and safe sleep surface. Transitioning to a toddler bed may also require a supportive mattress that meets both safety and comfort needs for growing children.

Q: What are the benefits of using a foam crib mattress?

A: Foam crib mattresses are known for their lightweight design, good support, and hypoallergenic properties. They often provide a comfortable sleep surface for babies and toddlers and can come in various thicknesses to cater to different preferences and needs.

Q: Can I use a waterproof cover with a crib mattress?

A: Yes, using a waterproof cover with a crib mattress is a common practice to protect the mattress from spills, accidents, and moisture. A waterproof cover can help prolong the life of the mattress and maintain a hygienic sleep environment for babies and toddlers.

Q: Are all crib mattresses suitable for mini cribs?

A: Not all crib mattresses are suitable for mini cribs due to differences in size and dimensions. When purchasing a mattress for a mini crib, it’s essential to ensure that the mattress dimensions align with the mini crib’s specifications to provide a safe and secure fit.


In conclusion, choosing the best crib mattress is crucial for providing your baby with a safe and comfortable sleep environment. The Avocado Organic Crib Mattress is an excellent choice with its organic materials and durable construction.

Similarly, the Serta Perfect Start Crib and Toddler Mattress, with its waterproof and stain-resistant features, offers optimal support for your little one’s peaceful slumber.

About the Author

Tanja is a proud mom to her twins Hailey and Bethany. She has blossomed into motherhood since giving birth, and she spends her time doting on the twins and giving them the best upbringing she possibly can.

She's forever experimenting with new parenting gadgets and baby formulas, and scours parenting blogs to gain insight from other moms.

Why Trust Us

Since 2010, Momtastic has provided millions of parents with a complete guide to raising a family in a healthy home by offering our expert advice on everything from car seats for kids to baking supplies for the kitchen. It takes a village to raise a family, and our experts are here to make sure every parent finds a little bit of that village in us.